Oliver at the Theatre Royal Drury Lane
Tuesday, June 2nd, 2009 by AnniSo, for my second theatrical excursion on my most recent trip to London, I had to see the production of Oliver that was happening. I went into it quite cynically, knowing that it’s a big expensive West End musical - probably on par with going to see Phantom in terms of it’s artistic value. For example, the woman playing Nancy (Jodie Prenger) got the job by winning in the UK reality series “I’d do Anything” which was how they cast the role. Come on, really? Having not seen this show I didn’t know or care who she was, and also Rowan Atkinson as Fagin didn’t interest me terribly as I’m not all that familiar with his work. But I really wanted to see it because of two actors that I love - Burn Gorman (from the show Torchwood) was playing Bill Sikes and Julian Bleach (who I saw in Shockheaded Peter a few times and is Davros on Dr. Who) was playing Mr. Sowerberry.
So, like Waiting For Godot, I went to see a play I don’t care for but it ended up being an excellent production. This perhaps became the theme of my trip.
Visually, this show really couldn’t have been more impressive. We ran in at the last minute and asked if they had any returns, so we ended up in the 8th row. Not having been to this theatre before, I didn’t realize it is the size of an opera house. It is massive. I think there were 4 balconies. Just amazing. And the set is designed to reach all the way up to the people in the 4th circle. So there was no reason to be sitting in the 8th row, it just happened to work out that way. But I sort of felt like I was IN the show, almost like the show was so big it just enveloped us in an attempt to play out to the back of the house, which is miles away from the stage.
The set was so amazing that even in the 8th row, my eyes couldn’t distinguish where the set pieces ended and where the backdrop began. Everything melded together so perfectly that when the street set came on, I literally couldn’t believe my eyes, it was that well done. And when the young boys take Oliver underground for the first time, the street level rises up on hydraulics and then they come through a hole in the false floor (a sewer grate) and then the stage transforms into Fagin’s lair before your eyes.
And then the audience applauds the set change.
Really, this is a glorious spectacle. But is it necessary? I mean I suppose it is, as tickets are selling like hotcakes. I mean, of course they would - Britain loves their reality TV stars, and Oliver is a family show - so lots of kids to sell tickets to. But Oliver itself is really not a good play. I understand why it gets done in community theatres around the world so often - there’s lots of parts and it’s fairly easy to put on, and most importantly, lots of roles for kids. But the play itself is actually pretty bad. It’s poorly written, there are extraneous characters that serve no purpose whatsoever (Widow Corney? Mrs. Bedwin? Mrs. Sowerberry? Why are they even there!?!?!) and the music isn’t even good. I would say there are a couple songs that are pretty - “Boy For Sale” has always had a melancholic charm to it, as well as the beginning of “Who Will Buy.” (Except the grammatical syntax of that song has always bugged me - the lyrics being “Who will buy, this wonderful morning?” and even as a child I wondered, who would want to buy the morning? That’s not even possible! So yeah - that needs a grammar do-over.) Oh, also I’ve always liked “Reviewing the Situation” although it sounds more like it should be in Fiddler on the Roof than in Oliver.
But really, the majority of the music is really, really bad (”I shall Scream?” Yikes.) And the plot, particularly at the end, is so full of holes it just about completely falls apart. Only a child or a dolt wouldn’t question the events that occur at the climax of this story. It really doesn’t make any sense. But I digress.
I have to say, Prenger did a great job with “Oom-pah-pah,” a really stupid, pointless act 2 opener that she made sound like a proper drinking tune. In fact, I think the English public did a great job choosing her, she was really quite good. Her singing and acting both were solid - and I appreciated the fact that she’s a real woman (i.e. kinda chunky.) Apparently on the show both Andrew Lloyd Weber and Cameron McIntosh both told her she was too fat for the role but she got the job anyway, so huzzah for that. I really did like her interpretation of the character. Nothing ground-breakingly new or different, but in a production of this size and commercial appeal, I’m sure you’re not really allowed to take too many liberties with characters that are already so well known and loved.
Rowan Atkinson was also a pleasant surprise. His Fagin was not at all hammy like I had expected. He carefully balanced the line between comic and darkly disturbing. Brilliant bit of casting - his performance was comical enough to keep children entertained, yet nuanced and complex enough to keep the adults interested. And although I haven’t ever watched Mr. Bean, I know it’s a lot of physical comedy, and watching him do Fagin I just went, oh, right - he’s got hardcore mime/clown training. His physical work was incredible. And somehow not over the top, even though he was playing the largest theatre ever. He was a joy to watch and I now get why he’s so famous in Britain.
Burn Gorman as Bill Sykes was more panto villain than I would have liked. I’m sure he was directed that way - and I know him from doing very subtle TV work, so this was really different territory. I think he did a good job but I wonder how much input he had in creating the character and how much of it was coerced direction. It was still great to see him do stage. And his song “My Name,” which I had completely forgotten about, he really did good things with - reminded me a bit of Epiphany from Sweeney. But in general he was too much of a stereotypical evil guy. And when the role is played that way, you have no idea why Nancy stays with him. Even tho she tells us. Over and over.
And of course Julian Bleach was his creepy, comic horror villain self. I wonder if he’s ever played a normal human? I’d like to see that sometime. Anyway his creepy brilliance was lost on this audience because his part was too small and he gets swallowed up by all the other stuff. Like pickpocketing orphans.
And I haven’t even mentioned the kids yet. They were ok. Really not the focal point of the production. I think “Where is Love” might be the sappiest song ever written, but the kid belted it out, rather than doing it in falsetto (which is how I am used to hearing it) and it worked much better. Much less saccharine when the kid is bordering on yelling, so his desperation is more apparent.
So - again, another bad play done extraordinarily well. One of the most expensive-looking shows I think I’ve ever seen. And even in the top price seats, still cheaper than Broadway.
