What can really be said about this monumental piece of theatre? Ranking in my top 3 favorite musicals of all time, I was thrilled to learn it was coming to NYC’s Carnegie Hall. But disappointed when I heard it would only be a 2 night concert version of the musical. I looked at it more like a backers’ audition. Hopefully bringing it to NY will get people excited about a possible Broadway run again, which has been on and off the table for years. Those pesky Christian protesters seem to be enough to scare off the lot of theatre producers because theatre goers these days do tend to be rather conservative. Particularly compared with British theatre goers, where the show ran for years, to rave reviews, and played in London’s Royal National Theatre. The sad (but unsurprising) irony is that most of the complaints the protesters have with the show, simply do not exist. And if any of them had ever actually seen it, they would know this first hand. But any mention of religious allegory in a satirical setting is enough to bring out the crazies.
But who cares about them, right? I still got to see my show that I love in NY, with an all new cast (except David Bedella as warm-up man/Satan, who originated the role). It was great to see the little changes (the words “mad” and “biscuit” are Americanized and switched to “crazy” and “cookie,” naturally) and hear new people singing the roles. Harvey Keitel as Jerry Springer (the only non-singing role) was disappointing in the first act. Flubbing lines and generally having low energy. But then in act 2, his acting chops really came out and he completely redeemed himself. Although he was much more of a low-key Jerry than I’d seen previously.
The cast was great. Solid. And with only 2 weeks of rehearsal, I was surprised to see how fully realized the production was. I thought it was just to be a concert version, but it was almost fully complete, with costumes and choreography, and much of it sung off-book. The orchestra and singers needed some tightening up, certainly, it wasn’t the cleanest thing I’ve heard, but again, 2 weeks rehearsal. And rather than set pieces, huge projections were used instead, and they were extremely effective (and cheaper!). Rather than use an actual burning cross at the end of act one, use a giant projection of one! Almost as effective. But not as eyebrow singeing.
I was thrilled to hear Emily Skinner sing “I wanna sing something Beautiful,” one of my favorite mini-arias. I didn’t like, however, that the character of Chantell, who is supposed to be in her 40s I believe, and quite obese, was played by a not-at-all-fat twenty-something actress. She sounded great, but I think very miscast.
What was most exciting to me was that a NY audience got to hear and see this show that I’ve been in love with for years. And to hear the audience roaring with laughter at all the jokes that I’ve come to know and love (and quote incessantly). It’s filthy and brilliant and hope it someday finds its place in a more permanent way onto the NY-scene. Maybe not Broadway; maybe Lincoln Center or BAM. Where audiences tend to be a bit more enlightened.
And did I mention they say fuck a lot?